‘Why is there something rather than nothing?’

Hume

Verified User
"Properly understood, the question of why there is something rather than nothing does not reify nothing, but instead treats ‘nothing’ as shorthand for ‘not anything’.

The question can be re-stated as “Why is it the case that there is something rather than it not being the case that there is something?” Or as I suggested earlier, we can simply ask, ‘Why does anything whatsoever exist?’. In neither case do we even use the word ‘nothing’.

 
"Properly understood, the question of why there is something rather than nothing does not reify nothing, but instead treats ‘nothing’ as shorthand for ‘not anything’.

The question can be re-stated as “Why is it the case that there is something rather than it not being the case that there is something?” Or as I suggested earlier, we can simply ask, ‘Why does anything whatsoever exist?’. In neither case do we even use the word ‘nothing’.

Strange loop fallacy.
 
"Properly understood, the question of why there is something rather than nothing does not reify nothing, but instead treats ‘nothing’ as shorthand for ‘not anything’.

The question can be re-stated as “Why is it the case that there is something rather than it not being the case that there is something?” Or as I suggested earlier, we can simply ask, ‘Why does anything whatsoever exist?’. In neither case do we even use the word ‘nothing’.

The question is moot. If there were nothing, the question wouldn't even be asked. Therefore, because there is something, is a given. That is, something exists and that's that as far as things go.
 
The question is moot. If there were nothing, the question wouldn't even be asked. Therefore, because there is something, is a given. That is, something exists and that's that as far as things go.
Very well said.
Hugo apparently ignores the Proof of Identity. Apparently, he isn't even sure he exists at all! :laugh:
 
The question is moot. If there were nothing, the question wouldn't even be asked. Therefore, because there is something, is a given. That is, something exists and that's that as far as things go.
Leibniz was first to ask, Why is there something and not nothing. He starts with concept of God having choice to make a world or have nothingness.
 
The question is moot. If there were nothing, the question wouldn't even be asked. Therefore, because there is something, is a given. That is, something exists and that's that as far as things go.
That's bad logic.

Of course it's not unexpected that we observe matter, energy, motion. But the observation itself does not explain the origin of matter, energy, and time.
 
That's bad logic.

Of course it's not unexpected that we observe matter, energy, motion. But the observation itself does not explain the origin of matter, energy, and time.
Nor does our world prove there has to be a world.
 
Back
Top