Senate Passes Bipartisan Criminal Justice Bill "First Step Act"

dukkha

Verified User
The First Step Act would expand job training and other programming aimed at reducing recidivism rates among federal prisoners. It also expands early-release programs and modifies sentencing laws, including mandatory minimum sentences for nonviolent drug offenders, to more equitably punish drug offenders.

But the legislation falls short of benchmarks set by a more expansive overhaul proposed in Congress during Barack Obama’s presidency and of the kinds of changes sought by some liberal and conservative activists targeting mass incarceration.

House leaders have pledged to pass the measure this week, and President Trump, whose support resuscitated a yearslong overhaul effort last month, said he would sign the bill.

Even as both sides acknowledged concessions, Tuesday’s vote was an important first step for the unlikely coalition of liberals and conservatives — including the American Civil Liberties Union, the American Conservative Union, Koch brothers and the liberal Center for American Progress — who locked arms in recent years and pushed lawmakers to reconsider the way the federal government administers justice three decades after the war on crime peaked. In one of this Congress’s final acts, every Democrat and all but 12 Republicans voted in favor of the legislation — an outcome that looked highly unlikely this month amid skepticism from Republican leaders.

For Republicans preparing to relinquish total control of Washington next month, the bill’s passage offered one final victory on their own terms and handed Mr. Trump a bipartisan policy achievement that he can tout as he seeks re-election. Liberals saw reason to celebrate, as well, even as they called for more aggressive changes: In gaining the support of Mr. Trump and so many Senate Republicans, they believe they have shifted the terms of policy debates around criminal justice in a way that could set the stage for additional changes on the federal level and in the states.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/18/us/politics/senate-criminal-justice-bill.html
 
Kanye and the kardashians convinced jared to talk to trump about this issue, and look what they got done.


Will the left thank trump and apologize to kanye for calling him an uncle tom?
 
Kushner earns praise for support of criminal justice reform
https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/kushner-credited-pushing-rare-bipartisan-bill-59895076
It was the first time many liberal advocates had set foot inside President Donald Trump's White House.

And they came at the invitation of presidential son-in-law Jared Kushner — a top White House adviser whom many liberal and good-government groups have criticized, questioning his lack of experience in government, potential conflicts of interest and cozy relationship with foreign leaders, including Saudi Arabia's crown prince.

But in White House conference rooms and lobbying trips to Capitol Hill, Kushner worked with advocates, legislators and others on both sides of the aisle to try to craft a deal to make the nation's criminal justice system fairer. Now Kushner, the likely subject of new investigations when Democrats take control of the House next year, is getting credit for helping to spearhead what could be the first major bipartisan legislative success of the Trump era: a first-in-a-generation criminal justice overhaul that passed the Senate Tuesday and is expected to pass the House later this week.

"I don't think this would have happened without him," said Sen. Corey Booker of New Jersey, a potential 2020 Democratic presidential contender
 
ROFL> WHAT ? bi-partisanship to help exiting felons from prison.....why do we care about THAT!

Now back to all Mueller all the Time
 
The First Step Act would expand job training and other programming aimed at reducing recidivism rates among federal prisoners. It also expands early-release programs and modifies sentencing laws, including mandatory minimum sentences for nonviolent drug offenders, to more equitably punish drug offenders.

How is this a good thing? How does this reduce recidivism? Any credible study that supports this idiotic notion?
 
How is this a good thing? How does this reduce recidivism? Any credible study that supports this idiotic notion?
basically it improves support for exiting prisoners. Now they get little except contact with their parole officer.
I'd have to look at the details, but it's very difficult to transition back to society for many
 
Truth Detector, there's a reason many states including red states like Texas have worked on prison reform and it's because giving long sentences and saying go F yourself has become too costly and those coming out of prison are nowhere near prepared to deal with the real world and end up right back in the system. That benefits no one.

This isn't about being soft on criminals it's about making us safer by helping criminals have opportunities other than just crime upon release. That is a good thing.
 
basically it improves support for exiting prisoners. Now they get little except contact with their parole officer.
I'd have to look at the details, but it's very difficult to transition back to society for many

Criminals have always had support. They choose NOT to accept it. Is there any evidence that this will actually reduce recidivism rates?

What we do know is this; over 90% of crimes are committed by a very small percentage of the population. Many of them are crimes after these people have been released. What we also know is that crime rates go down when we enforce our existing laws and keep this small percentage of repeat criminals OFF our streets.

How is reducing their time behind bars going to reduce crimes?
 
Truth Detector, there's a reason many states including red states like Texas have worked on prison reform and it's because giving long sentences and saying go F yourself has become too costly and those coming out of prison are nowhere near prepared to deal with the real world and end up right back in the system. That benefits no one.

This isn't about being soft on criminals it's about making us safer by helping criminals have opportunities other than just crime upon release. That is a good thing.

Again I will ask; where is the evidence that such tactics reduce recidivism rates?
 
Hello Reverend_Hellh0und,

Kanye and the kardashians convinced jared to talk to trump about this issue, and look what they got done.


Will the left thank trump and apologize to kanye for calling him an uncle tom?

I applaud the effort and will thank the President after he signs it.

I have no apology for Kayne. I never called him anything. Neither I nor any individual speaks for 'the left.'
 
Criminals have always had support. They choose NOT to accept it. Is there any evidence that this will actually reduce recidivism rates?

What we do know is this; over 90% of crimes are committed by a very small percentage of the population. Many of them are crimes after these people have been released. What we also know is that crime rates go down when we enforce our existing laws and keep this small percentage of repeat criminals OFF our streets.

How is reducing their time behind bars going to reduce crimes?
it doesn't mean if they commit another crime they don't violate parole, it just means that getting out of jail can be a very difficult experience
they need all the support they can get
 
it doesn't mean if they commit another crime they don't violate parole, it just means that getting out of jail can be a very difficult experience
they need all the support they can get

Once again; how is reducing their punishment give them more hope? Perhaps it only shortens the time between crimes. You do realize there are myriads of programs currently available to ex-cons. They CHOOSE not to take them.

I'd like to see the study that supports the idea that this will reduce recidivism rates.
 
Hello anatta,

ROFL> WHAT ? bi-partisanship to help exiting felons from prison.....why do we care about THAT!

Because it costs about 30 grand a year to keep somebody in lock-down. It also deprives the federal budget of any revenue from taxes they might pay if they were out and working. And it often deprives children of having a father figure. Children from functional families are less likely to get in trouble themselves when they get older. Excessive sentencing costs our society and it costs us all.
 
Hello noise,

The First Step Act would expand job training and other programming aimed at reducing recidivism rates among federal prisoners. It also expands early-release programs and modifies sentencing laws, including mandatory minimum sentences for nonviolent drug offenders, to more equitably punish drug offenders.

But the legislation falls short of benchmarks set by a more expansive overhaul proposed in Congress during Barack Obama’s presidency and of the kinds of changes sought by some liberal and conservative activists targeting mass incarceration.

House leaders have pledged to pass the measure this week, and President Trump, whose support resuscitated a yearslong overhaul effort last month, said he would sign the bill.

Even as both sides acknowledged concessions, Tuesday’s vote was an important first step for the unlikely coalition of liberals and conservatives — including the American Civil Liberties Union, the American Conservative Union, Koch brothers and the liberal Center for American Progress — who locked arms in recent years and pushed lawmakers to reconsider the way the federal government administers justice three decades after the war on crime peaked. In one of this Congress’s final acts, every Democrat and all but 12 Republicans voted in favor of the legislation — an outcome that looked highly unlikely this month amid skepticism from Republican leaders.

For Republicans preparing to relinquish total control of Washington next month, the bill’s passage offered one final victory on their own terms and handed Mr. Trump a bipartisan policy achievement that he can tout as he seeks re-election. Liberals saw reason to celebrate, as well, even as they called for more aggressive changes: In gaining the support of Mr. Trump and so many Senate Republicans, they believe they have shifted the terms of policy debates around criminal justice in a way that could set the stage for additional changes on the federal level and in the states.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/18/us/politics/senate-criminal-justice-bill.html

I am very encouraged that this legislation is passing. I presume the few hold-outs in not voting for this are on the take from the prisons-for-profit industry. I know some Democrats had objections because it did not go far enough, but not so great objections that they didn't vote for the measure. Shame on anyone who is serving the prisons-for-profit industry instead of the people who elected them.
 
Once again; how is reducing their punishment give them more hope? Perhaps it only shortens the time between crimes. You do realize there are myriads of programs currently available to ex-cons. They CHOOSE not to take them.

I'd like to see the study that supports the idea that this will reduce recidivism rates.
some state do help,some not so much. it federalizes the help.

Reducing the sentencing is a bit more controversial for some -
I have no problem with it since i'm libertarian on drug possession
 
The First Step Act would expand job training and other programming aimed at reducing recidivism rates among federal prisoners. It also expands early-release programs and modifies sentencing laws, including mandatory minimum sentences for nonviolent drug offenders, to more equitably punish drug offenders.

But the legislation falls short of benchmarks set by a more expansive overhaul proposed in Congress during Barack Obama’s presidency and of the kinds of changes sought by some liberal and conservative activists targeting mass incarceration.



House leaders have pledged to pass the measure this week, and President Trump, whose support resuscitated a yearslong overhaul effort last month, said he would sign the bill.

Even as both sides acknowledged concessions, Tuesday’s vote was an important first step for the unlikely coalition of liberals and conservatives — including the American Civil Liberties Union, the American Conservative Union, Koch brothers and the liberal Center for American Progress — who locked arms in recent years and pushed lawmakers to reconsider the way the federal government administers justice three decades after the war on crime peaked. In one of this Congress’s final acts, every Democrat and all but 12 Republicans voted in favor of the legislation — an outcome that looked highly unlikely this month amid skepticism from Republican leaders.

For Republicans preparing to relinquish total control of Washington next month, the bill’s passage offered one final victory on their own terms and handed Mr. Trump a bipartisan policy achievement that he can tout as he seeks re-election. Liberals saw reason to celebrate, as well, even as they called for more aggressive changes: In gaining the support of Mr. Trump and so many Senate Republicans, they believe they have shifted the terms of policy debates around criminal justice in a way that could set the stage for additional changes on the federal level and in the states.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/18/us/politics/senate-criminal-justice-bill.html


His only policy achievement in 2 years.
 
basically it improves support for exiting prisoners. Now they get little except contact with their parole officer.
I'd have to look at the details, but it's very difficult to transition back to society for many

I'll have to read through the bill to know what to say here, but it's time to let the marijuana and crack users caught 20 years ago out of jail now!

And the idea of White Judges always giving Minorities maximum sentences for first time offenders for everything as a standard in certain courts, needs to change as well.

And when a man/woman get's out of prison, they should have earned their way back to voting in federal elections again- in every United State!

Hopefully those things will be addressed in the new Bill!
 
The issue with criminal behavior is not what to do with them after the behavior has become a trait, but rather, attack the causes before they become criminals.

6 traits that lead to criminal behavior

Dysfunctional family: One of the most common traits includes a lack of family support, both emotionally and otherwise. An individual’s family lacks the ability to problem solve and often is unable to communicate effectively. Family members often don’t possess the ability to express emotions in an appropriate manner. More often than not, they are also involved with criminal activity.

Substance abuse: The use of drugs or alcohol that significantly affect one’s ability to engage in a successful and productive lifestyle. There is often an increased tolerance to substances, in addition to an inability to stop use.

Anti-social values: This is also known as criminal thinking. It includes criminal rationalization or the belief that their criminal behavior was justified. Individuals possessing this trait often blame others for their negative behavior, and show a lack of remorse.

Criminal Peers: Individuals with this trait often have peers that are associated with criminal activities. Most are often involved with substance abuse including drugs or alcohol. Peer influence often persuades the individual to engage in criminal behavior. They will also typically present with a lack of pro-social community involvement.

Anti-social personality: These traits often include atypical behavior conducted prior to the age of fifteen and can include, running away, skipping school, fighting, possessing weapons, lying, stealing and damage to either animals or property.

Low self-control: This involves one’s ability to control temperament and impulsivity. People that carry this trait often do things that they didn’t plan, and will fail to think before acting. The mindset is of the here and now, and not on the consequences of the behavior.


https://www.policeone.com/corrections/articles/8552534-6-traits-that-lead-to-criminal-behavior/
 
Back
Top