Moral relativism: open discussion

[Yakuda]

'Nice try'?? They are YOUR fallacies. YOU made them. Only YOU can correct them.

RQAA. DON'T TRY TO DENY YOUR OWN POSTS!

An act is not a moral.
You just said it again.

Yes and I will say it again An act is not a moral.

Obviously you need it simplified. Is there any difference between offering aid and comfort to an injured person and beating an injured person to death?

 

[Into the Night]

Yes and I will say it again An act is not a moral.

But then you claim it is. Which is it, dude?

Obviously you need it simplified.

Simplified? Okay, I'll see what you come up with.

Is there any difference between offering aid and comfort to an injured person and beating an injured person to death?

Yes.

 

[Jerry Mathers]

New thread. Same result.

neocon noahide are fucking scary.

 

[Yakuda]

But then you claim it is. Which is it, dude?

Simplified? Okay, I'll see what you come up with.

Yes.

Why is it different?

 

[Into the Night]

Why is it different?

One kills, the other aids said person.

 

[Jerry Mathers]

One kills, the other aids said person.

an act kills and a moral does not ?

you live in retard-ville.

 

[ZenMode]

I don't discuss graphic details to satisfy your perversions.

I am not trying to convince any teenage girl of anything.

Some are forced into it, yes. Some do it voluntarily.

Some places don't use anesthetic, yes. Some do.

Okay. Don't describe it in graphic detail. I'm certain that you have enough grasp of the English language to talk in generalities.

For example, You could talk about the fact that you are convincing a teenage girl to do something that she can't possibly understand the long-term ramifications of. You can talk about the denial of physical please that she can never recover.

You could also talk about the possibility that the girl is being forced, against her will, to do something that she can't possibly understand the long-term ramifications of. You could also talk about the excruciating pain involved in what is being done.

Convincing a teenage girl to do something she can't possibly understand , likely using the leverage of religion and eternal punishment, is immoral in itself.

So, do you agree that there is a moral aspect to cutting off a teenage girl's clitoris?

New thread. Same result.

 

[Yakuda]

One kills, the other aids said person.

Very good. So its inherent in the act of beating an injured person to death that the injured person dies. Thats not my opinion thats an objective fact.

 

[IBDaMann]

morality is the set of attitudes and behaviors that facilitate voluntary, cooperative and mutually beneficial relationships.

Morality is consensual sex?

 

[IBDaMann]

You're preaching satanic moral relativism.

It looked like plain ol' vanilla moral relativism to me. Where did you see Satanism?

And you suck big pharma cock

So that's what BPC stands for! I thought it was "bits per character."

How are you so intimately familiar with sucking BPC?

 

[IBDaMann]

... an opinion doesnt take from another huamn being something that doesnt belong to them.

Into the Night already covered this. Actions do that. You offer your opinion on the action, and then you deny that you offered your opinion on the action.

Your objective is to get your subjective opinions declared as objective truth. Good luck with that.

Opinion are fucking useless.

When you declare something immoral, you are offering your opinion.

Actions are what effect people.

Great, you agree with Into the Night while pretending to disagree.

So according to you genocide of the jews was both moral and immoral at the same time

No, he only has one opinion on the genocide of the Jews, not two simultaneous and opposing opinions.

Thats your argument in a nutshell.

Did you just assign a bogus argument to Into the Night, and then attack him for that bogus argument that he never made?

 

[IBDaMann]

Yes an intrinsic attribute of FGM is that its immoral.

In your opinion.

I havent denied a thing.

You have denied that your opinion is your opinion.

You want to insist an act is a moral.

You need to read for comprehension. That is not what he insists.

 

[Into the Night]

an act kills and a moral does not ?

you live in retard-ville.

No moral has been mentioned here, NoName.

 

[Into the Night]

Very good. So its inherent in the act of beating an injured person to death that the injured person dies.

By definition.

Thats not my opinion thats an objective fact.

Since you defined the scenario, and we are talking about the same scenario, it is a fact. The scenario is the object, yes, making the fact objective.

 

[Into the Night]

It looked like plain ol' vanilla moral relativism to me. Where did you see Satanism?


So that's what BPC stands for! I thought it was "bits per character."

How are you so intimately familiar with sucking BPC?

He sees 'Satanism' in pretty much anything he disagrees with or doesn't understand. He sees Nazis there too.

 

[Jerry Mathers]

It looked like plain ol' vanilla moral relativism to me. Where did you see Satanism?


So that's what BPC stands for! I thought it was "bits per character."

How are you so intimately familiar with sucking BPC?

the inversion of right and wrong is satan's middle name. though it's unwieldy as a name.

 

[Yakuda]

By definition.

Since you defined the scenario, and we are talking about the same scenario, it is a fact. The scenario is the object, yes, making the fact objective.

And making the immorality of the act objective. Thanks

 

[ZenMode]

I don't discuss graphic details to satisfy your perversions.

Okay. Don't describe it in graphic detail. I'm certain that you have enough grasp of the English language to talk in generalities.

For example, You could talk about the fact that you are convincing a teenage girl to do something that she can't possibly understand the long-term ramifications of. You can talk about the denial of physical please that she can never recover.

You could also talk about the possibility that the girl is being forced, against her will, to do something that she can't possibly understand the long-term ramifications of. You could also talk about the excruciating pain involved in what is being done.

Convincing a teenage girl to do something she can't possibly understand , likely using the leverage of religion and eternal punishment, is immoral in itself.

So, do you agree that there is (a) moral aspect to cutting off a teenage girl's clitoris?

New thread. Same result.

 

[AProudLefty]

Why is it wrong for someone to try to cut your penis off?

 

[Into the Night]

the inversion of right and wrong is satan's middle name. though it's unwieldy as a name.

Random words. No apparent coherency.
Illiteracy: Failure to capitalize sentence. Failure to capitalize proper noun.