Africa in the news
- Thread starter Diogenes
- Start date
"The global left's obsession with turning a failing state into an ideological blueprint is the height of intellectual laziness and political delusion.
The fact that Zohran Mamdani, a Democrat Socialist politician from New York, looks at South Africa and sees a model to emulate proves just how detached Western progressive academics are from the brutal realities of African governance.
They treat lived economic tragedies as experimental playgrounds for their virtue signaling.
To look at South Africa and see an economic North Star requires a breathtaking level of willful blindness.
There is absolutely nothing good to copy from the South African reality. The country is trapped in a low-growth loop, with astronomical unemployment rates and a completely suffocated private sector.
The municipal water networks are collapsing, and the national rail and logistics corridors are in shambles. Law and order have effectively broken down, turning the country into one of the most violent, high-crime zones outside an active war theater.
Decades of porous borders and failed regional foreign policy have fueled explosive, unmanaged migration, sparking violent grassroots conflict.
Mamdani and the global left look at this smoking ruin and somehow see a progressive paradise, simply because the political rhetoric sounds nice in a Manhattan lecture hall.
The core defect of the socialist fantasy is that it is entirely obsessed with distributing wealth but utterly incapable of creating it. The strategy is always to "eat the rich" and penalize success. They overtax the productive middle class and the corporate sector to fund massive, unsustainable social grant systems.
When you destroy a business-friendly landscape, capital flees the country. Factories close. Intellectual property leaves. You cannot distribute wealth that has already fled the borders.
Once the rich are "eaten" and the business class is gone, the state is left with nothing but an impoverished population and a broken tax base. The "comrades" end up presiding over equalized misery rather than shared prosperity.
Western leftists like Mamdani love South Africa because they only engage with its symbols, the progressive constitution, the anti-apartheid history, the radical rhetoric of economic transformation.
They don't have to live with the rolling blackouts, the dry taps, or the fear of home invasions. They champion ideologies that kill production and development because they are completely insulated from the consequences of their own ideas.
Copying South Africa's current economic trajectory isn't a progressive strategy; it is a blueprint for national suicide."
View: https://x.com/FaraiMazhindu/status/2090674452438675760?s=20
The fact that Zohran Mamdani, a Democrat Socialist politician from New York, looks at South Africa and sees a model to emulate proves just how detached Western progressive academics are from the brutal realities of African governance.
They treat lived economic tragedies as experimental playgrounds for their virtue signaling.
To look at South Africa and see an economic North Star requires a breathtaking level of willful blindness.
There is absolutely nothing good to copy from the South African reality. The country is trapped in a low-growth loop, with astronomical unemployment rates and a completely suffocated private sector.
The municipal water networks are collapsing, and the national rail and logistics corridors are in shambles. Law and order have effectively broken down, turning the country into one of the most violent, high-crime zones outside an active war theater.
Decades of porous borders and failed regional foreign policy have fueled explosive, unmanaged migration, sparking violent grassroots conflict.
Mamdani and the global left look at this smoking ruin and somehow see a progressive paradise, simply because the political rhetoric sounds nice in a Manhattan lecture hall.
The core defect of the socialist fantasy is that it is entirely obsessed with distributing wealth but utterly incapable of creating it. The strategy is always to "eat the rich" and penalize success. They overtax the productive middle class and the corporate sector to fund massive, unsustainable social grant systems.
When you destroy a business-friendly landscape, capital flees the country. Factories close. Intellectual property leaves. You cannot distribute wealth that has already fled the borders.
Once the rich are "eaten" and the business class is gone, the state is left with nothing but an impoverished population and a broken tax base. The "comrades" end up presiding over equalized misery rather than shared prosperity.
Western leftists like Mamdani love South Africa because they only engage with its symbols, the progressive constitution, the anti-apartheid history, the radical rhetoric of economic transformation.
They don't have to live with the rolling blackouts, the dry taps, or the fear of home invasions. They champion ideologies that kill production and development because they are completely insulated from the consequences of their own ideas.
Copying South Africa's current economic trajectory isn't a progressive strategy; it is a blueprint for national suicide."
View: https://x.com/FaraiMazhindu/status/2090674452438675760?s=20
