What is the practical difference, Hormuz is blocked either way.

Jarod

Well-known member
Contributor
What is the practical difference if the US is blocading Hormuz or Iran is?

Its blocked either way, right? We want it open.
 
What is the practical difference if the US is blocading Hormuz or Iran is?

Its blocked either way, right? We want it open.
The US is only interested in ships that are paying the ransom to Iran and in collusion with Iran to get passage through the strait. Observation of ships on maritime tracking sites seems to indicate that only Chinese vessels are doing this, and likely aren't having to pay the ransom.

Iran has indicated that they will let ships from countries allied or friendly to them pass going on the Iranian side of the strait in their waters. All others must pay the ransom or risk potential attack.

It is not so much blocked as it is threatened by Iran. The potential risk is Iran will attack a ship transiting without their explicit approval.
 
The US is only interested in ships that are paying the ransom to Iran and in collusion with Iran to get passage through the strait. Observation of ships on maritime tracking sites seems to indicate that only Chinese vessels are doing this, and likely aren't having to pay the ransom.

Iran has indicated that they will let ships from countries allied or friendly to them pass going on the Iranian side of the strait in their waters. All others must pay the ransom or risk potential attack.

It is not so much blocked as it is threatened by Iran. The potential risk is Iran will attack a ship transiting without their explicit approval.
Then why is traffic at a stop? Nobody going through?
 
Then why is traffic at a stop? Nobody going through?
Yes, there are ships going through, mostly Chinese. You can see that here:

 
What is the practical difference if the US is blocading Hormuz or Iran is?

Its blocked either way, right? We want it open.
If the strait is not freely open to maritime navigation and maritime insurance companies are frightened off, then the situation is intolerable.

It's extraordinary that MAGA put us in a position to wage a war just to return the strait back to the maritime navigational status it was before Trump's War.
 
If the strait is not freely open to maritime navigation and maritime insurance companies are frightened off, then the situation is intolerable.

It's extraordinary that MAGA put us in a position to wage a war just to return the strait back to the maritime navigational status it was before Trump's War.
‘Just to return the strait back’ is the same kind of dishonest euphemism as saying the bin Laden raid was just a routine effort to improve neighborhood security.
 
Back
Top