BattleofHodow
New member
Undocumented workers are largely migratory workers, which means they follow the seasonality of jobs around the country. They aren't in the same place every time they work. So you would need to fill the demand for labor within the region, locale, area that need exists. Now, I could be wrong, but in many of those counties where this work takes place, there already aren't a lot of "able bodied folks able to work but aren't". This is dangerous because it assumes you can simply replace 1:1, but those migrants bring skills to the job that others don't have. And yes, farm work requires skilled workers.
1. They don't undercut taxes, they pay taxes that they aren't able to collect...like Social Security.
2. They should unionize.
3. The reason you don't pluck a random Joe to fill the job is because the job changes with the season, and is never in the same place. So you have an American worker who can only work these jobs during the season the need exists. What happens once the season is over and the crops are harvested? Back to government assistance...so we're just repeating the pattern over and over.
Because tying someone's value to their job is precisely why we are in this mess in the first place.
Illegals pay far less taxes for sure.
There's a partial reason why our property taxes skyrocketed in Brewster region &,Pawling region with the arrival of Illegals.