Grok: Mainstream and left-leaning media largely framed Daniel Penny negatively as a killer/vigilante (often emphasizing race and excessive force), while coverage of Karmelo Anthony prominently featured and amplified his self-defense claim as a teen, with racial angles from supporters—though his conviction limited the "hero" narrative.
Jordan Neely (black, homeless, history of mental illness and violence) entered a subway car, shouted threats (e.g., "I'm ready to die," "I'll hurt you"), scaring passengers. Penny (White, Marine veteran) and others restrained him with a chokehold lasting several minutes until Neely went limp and died (ruled homicide by neck compression). Penny was charged with manslaughter and negligent homicide; acquitted on the latter after a deadlock on the former. Witnesses described Neely as a clear threat.
Progressive outlets called Penny a "subway strangler," "killer," "murderer," or "vigilante." Coverage highlighted race (white killer vs. black victim), homelessness, and "excessive force" (holding too long). Outlets like The Guardian discussed "white vigilante crime" patterns and "lynching" rhetoric; some compared it to cases like Zimmerman/Rittenhouse.
Karmelo Anthony (black) stabbed Austin Metcalf (white) in the chest during an altercation at a track meet. Anthony sat uninvited under Metcalf's team tent; words were exchanged, Metcalf (and others) told him to leave. Anthony warned Metcalf "touch me and see what happen". Metcalf pushed him. Anthony pulled a knife from his bag, stabbed, and fled after disposing of the murder weapon. He admitted it when apprehended, claiming self-defense. The jury rejected this (no deadly threat justified lethal force;, convicting him of murder and sentencing to 35 years.
Mainstream and left-leaning media heavily pushed a "self-defense" angle (terrified teen vs. white "aggressor/bully/mob"), with racial undertones. Many outlets amplified the racial flashpoint, protests, and "legal lynching" rhetoric from supporters/family. Mainstream coverage (ABC, CBS, Fox, AP) reported the self-defense claim as factual, downplaying the prosecutors' view that it was provocation/escalation by a black teen with a knife.