Mott the Hoople
Sweet Jane
You present a couple of different perspectives. Four years ago Republicans (barely) controlled the Presidency and the Legislature. Today the Democrats (barely) control the Presidency and Legislature. It goes back and fourth. So whether it's a broad coalition or a smaller one I don't think it matters all that much.
I'll acknowledge as a Republican I have concerns over this idea that we should become a more blue collar (white) working class party. That's not a growing group and if the idea is you either support Trump's vision of the country, or get out (of the party), that's not going to work.
Me thinks that's what will happen as that is exactly what happened to me. I was essentially told not to let the door hit me in the ass on the way out because I'm a moderate who embraces egalitarianism and because I reject failed supply side economic policy in favor of a blend of Keyensian and Monetarist economic policy.
Point being...if it can happen to me and other former GOP moderates.....
If the GOP was dominated by folks like you...Id probably would still be a Republican but it's not.
The vast majority will go w/ trump.........